Review: DC K.O.: All Fight trade paperback (DC Comics)

DC K.O.: All Fight

Arguably DC K.O.: All Fight is where the real DC K.O. happens. There are fights in DC K.O., no doubt, particularly the tag teams. But each of its issues only has so many pages to spare, and while I liked Javi Fernandez as a nontraditional choice on the art, I’m not sure his sketchy style has really stuck with me for the fights.

Enter the “All Fight Month”, eight issues of mostly one-on-one fights falling between DC K.O. #2 and #3 that more fully fulfills the promise of the series. Granted the fight scenes in the 1990s DC Versus Marvel sometimes didn’t last much longer than the ones in DC K.O. proper, but I’m reminded of that series here — a vibe, as it were, of the “who’s stronger” action figure game.

The issues range. Some are dedicated “specials,” and so the fights within are focused on the characters in play. Others are regular series issues, weaving between the titular fights and their own subplots, and so reading them in the All Fight trade is less cohesive, with more distractions. Smartly, all the “All Fight” issues contain a connected throughway that gives this month an internal “plot”; it is terribly thin, but in contrast to the regular series issues, I appreciated that nod toward “All Fight” as a story in and of itself.

[Review contains spoilers]

As I’ve mentioned before, the best part of All Fight is that the characters get to choose a multiversal “form” a couple times in their fights. That’s nowhere in DC K.O. proper nor in the first “All Fight” story I read independently, from Aquaman Vol. 2: Justice League Blue, so I wasn’t aware of it initially and it’s proceeded to delight me ever since. Aside from this simply being a chance for me to geek out over Joshua Williamson in Superman vs. Captain Atom presenting Captain Atom in his Armageddon 2001 Monarch form, we also see the various writers exercising “everything happened” continuity patches — that Captain Atom, buffeted by multiversal mayhem, was once Monarch, that Guy Gardner’s Warrior form existed, that Etrigan does seem to have once been a Demon Knight.

[See the latest DC trade solicitations.]

There is not, I’ll grant, a great amount of suspense to the proceedings, even if for some reason you haven’t already read DC K.O. Only one title character doesn’t win their bout among the regular series issues, and that’s the Flash in Mark Waid’s Flash #28 — but even here, it’s Jay Garrick versus Green Lantern Guy Gardner, not title Flash Wally West. (In Superman #33, it’s still the hometown fighter, Lex Luthor, who wins.) In the rest, I don’t think it’s much of a surprise, for reasons both logical and likely of meta-importance, that Superman beats Captain Atom, Wonder Woman beats Lobo, and that Red Hood beats Joker but then the Joker actually wins.

About the only one I thought could go either way was Leah Williams' Harley Quinn vs. Zatanna. Ostensibly Zatanna could just magic Harley to death, but Harley gets in an early throat blow that puts them on more even ground. What follows is surprisingly bloody, leaning into darker elements of each of the two characters; not totally remembering this moment in DC K.O., I really wasn’t sure if it would be DC darling Harley or the more-powerful Zee who’d come out on top. (It’s Zatanna in the end, what we might notch as a bold choice by DC.)

There’s a common theme among the issues of the losing heroes essentially giving up their tournament spot to the winner. DC K.O. is shaky ground that I don’t think the creative teams ever quite figured out, how to reason out heroes beating other heroes to a pulp even within a cosmic fight club and even with humanity on the line. There’s outliers, but in rapid succession we see Swamp Thing, Harley, and Flash Jay Garrick all essentially cede their positions. Across different creative teams, I wondered if that demonstrated a shared uncertainty how to choose a victor between warring heroes.

Among “best” issues, again, I really can’t beat Williamson evoking Monarch and the “Exile” Superman, plus Sean Izaakse doing a pretty good Dan Jurgens impression, and that Williamson has Captain Atom yell “Eat an origin bomb!” with unironic abandon. As mentioned on Bleeding Cool and elsewhere, Joelle Jones' Wonder Woman vs. Lobo has a real Alan Grant/Keith Giffen flavor, with artist Jason Howard evoking Simon Bisley. The loopiness is not what Jones' previous work had led me to expect, but I’m very pleased she got the whole tone of a Lobo book here, God clipping His toenails and all. (Pity only the implication that Wonder Woman can’t defeat Lobo without help.)

Williamson also does well with his Lex Luthor character study, with art by Absolute Wonder Woman’s Hayden Sherman. But surely the big gun here, no pun intended, is Williamson and Scott Snyder’s Red Hood vs. the Joker. (That the DC K.O. leads take the time for this one-off obviously bespeaks their interest in it.) Jason Todd being allowed to kill the Joker is a wise premise in and of itself, which the writers don’t hesitate to take advantage of. Really the Joker killing Jason has been picked over to crumbs, but the idea that Jason held back originally so as not to kill the Joker is a new one.

It felt unnecessary for the writers to offer a new explanation for Jason’s “Red Hood” moniker, even a little silly (“Red Hood,” we’re told, in reference to a Gotham “neighborhood”), but again, there’s obviously strong feelings to warrant an issue by DC’s creative leads. Kudos Giuseppe Camuncoli (I think it is) with a Jim Aparo impression, though I wasn’t sure about the page where Jason, drawn by Dustin Nguyen (I think, too) could choose from forms not his own, including the Flying Graysons (Robin Dick Grayson) and Red Robin (Tim Drake).

I have not looked back to see how well the prolonged sequence of the Darkseid-controlled Booster Gold fighting the Quantum Quorum through DC K.O.: All Fight actually dovetails with DC K.O. I can say that reading the main book, I didn’t sense I was missing this halting eight-part sequence (Darkseid fights the Time Trapper. Then the World Forger arrives. Then Darkseid fights the World Forger, and so on). Still, the best way to read DC K.O. will likely be in the inevitable sequentially ordered omnibus (and subsequent DC Finest), sticking these issues between the second and third chapter of the other.

[Includes original and variant covers]

Rating 2.5

Start the Conversation

To post a comment, you may need to temporarily allow "cross-site tracking" in your browser of choice.