Review: Batman/Superman: World's Finest Vol. 9: The Merger hardcover/paperback (DC Comics)

Batman/Superman: World's Finest Vol. 9: The Merger

Since Mark Waid’s lackluster World’s Finest Eclipso story a couple volumes back, this title has been on the upswing, and I liked Batman/Superman: World’s Finest Vol. 9: The Merger well enough, too.

Two of the three stories collected here hearken back to earlier World’s Finest issues, which isn’t much but contributes to the sense of this as a series rather than an anthology, which I like better. The stories are funny and exciting; where any of them fall down for me is where my expectations perhaps outpace Waid’s purposes, or in certain tics I detect in Waid’s writing that break the illusions this title tightly holds.

[Review contains spoilers]

The first two stories, “We’re Not Dating!!” and “The Merger,” each concern themselves with World’s Finest’s best example of ongoing storylines. “Dating” is the next chapter of Waid’s doomed Robin/Supergirl team-ups, which when all is said and done deserve their own independent collection; “Merger” brings back the character we’re apparently calling “Fusion,” a Superman-Batman-Green Lantern hybrid from World’s Finest Vol. 1. If there wasn’t much to Fusion, then the character’s design at least immediately demanded action figures and Funko Pops!, and it’s real restraint on DC’s part that we’re only seeing him again in the comics now.

[See the latest DC trade solicitations.]

I continue to be eager for Waid to write a modern-day Nightwing/Supergirl team-up, given that his Robin Dick Grayson is so outrageously nerdy that I’m curious to see the two relate on more level ground (clock Dick in “civilian clothes” done in his Robin color scheme). If the “distaste to admiration to distaste” plot of “Dating” is predictable, that’s verily the point, and this hilarious untold history is often more interesting than another Superman/Batman team-up. (Equally, given this somewhat rectonned friendship between Dick and Kara, I’d also like to see Waid revisit Supergirl’s death in Crisis through this lens.)

Without getting prurient, “Dating” reaches its almost-end with Supergirl and Robin kissing, and the following page declares “The next morning,” suggesting that they … y’know. The gag is that they’re in the Robin-mobile and someone has pressed the emergency alarm, I guess when they woke up but maybe they’re still … y’know? Then Batman breaks in to find Robin and Supergirl still fully costumed in a kind of chaste semi-embrace, which is to say not y’know and also not looking around for the alert beacon as the dialogue suggests.

All of which is to say, I wondered if something went wrong at the end of this issue between words and art and lettering; no one quite seems to be on the same page as to what’s happening or what’s being suggested. Throughout, I rather felt the editors needed to be taking a stronger hand; Waid’s reference to “Gymkata” is at least of the 1980s when World’s Finest is more or less set, though it feels very much “of Waid” and not the office worker who gets the dialogue. But references to “ghosting” and podcasts and the death of Tupac Shakur are all anachronisms that don’t quite jibe, plus Waid’s use of the word “jackanapes” at least twice in three issues … there’s too obviously a specific writer here, the very hard edges that editors are meant to smooth down.1

The high concept of “Merger” is that Batman and Superman have to face a “merged” Joker and Lex Luthor, though I didn’t feel that made greater use of the characters than what we’d seen previously. The real hook as mentioned is Fusion, a composite Superman-Batman with a cooler red face mask, who’s now stored in the Fortress of Solitude just waiting for a writer to use him in the present day.

But “Merger” takes its most unexpected swing when the Joker and Luthor, powered by infinite knowledge, reveal Superman and Batman’s identities to the world. What follows feels a tad self-indulgent, Waid writing a three-page “Lois reacts to Clark’s identity” scene, given everyone’s aware none of this is “real” beyond this story.

At the same time, for a tale already with Silver/Bronze Age “imaginary story” tendencies, the whole bit seemed true to the times. Like, I’d believe if this story was published in the 1970s that there would be this tragic romance Lois scene, I’m just not sure I’d have made the same decision as Waid to take it that far in the here and now.

I might’ve misspoken suggesting that the book’s final story, “Day for Night,” doesn’t continue any ongoing threads from World’s Finest. It is at the very least self-referential, featuring Earth-3 versions of the Doom Patrol and the Metal Men, both Silver/Bronze Age stalwarts that appeared in the early issues of Waid’s World’s Finest. That much is fun, traveling with Ultraman and Owlman through unexplored corners of Earth-3, as is the end-of-part-one reveal of our (Earth-1) heroes in danger.

But of the three stories in Merger, this one sat worst with me. There is Superwoman’s pregnancy, what’s been a major plot point in more modern stories but that seems dropped here with no purpose; what felt an uninspiring Riddler/Joker mashup; and the swift final page suggestion of the heroic Riddler and his compatriots going after the Earth-3 Swamp Thing, a more compelling idea than most of what came before. I was also disappointed that Waid didn’t in some way foreshadow the significant effect Ultraman would have on Superman and his son Jon, though I recognize that wasn’t Waid’s story, not his circus, and so on.

But for a one-off volume in a series full of one-off volumes, Batman/Superman: World’s Finest Vol. 9: The Merger is not bad. Next time around brings the 50th issue and more Robin and Supergirl, I think. Hope the upward trend continues.

[Includes original and variant covers]


  1. Waid had the same problem with incessant, incongruous use of the word “jobber” in DC K.O.: Justice League Unlimited.  ↩︎

Rating 2.5

Start the Conversation

To post a comment, you may need to temporarily allow "cross-site tracking" in your browser of choice.